Anything Photoshop or Photography


Image of view from Edinburgh Castle, ScotlandI don’t know where everyone else is, but I am getting so totally confused about all the new software-plugin releases that have come out in recent days/weeks. I was hooked on plugins since I bought Nik Viveza at Christmas of 2009. I remember being nervous about paying so much for it, but loved it right from the beginning (and now it is free!!!). Over the years I have become totally immersed in what can be done with all the plugins available – and wish I could afford to get them all (sigh). So in this wordy blog I will try to sort this out.

As a quick example, let’s talk about Viveza 2 again. I downloaded the first beta version of Lightroom and never looked back. Lots of people said Nik Viveza was just a copy of what Lightroom (or Adobe Camera Raw)  could do for an image. Yes, it did similar things, but still was a lot different in my mind. Flash forward and I still use Viveza on nearly every post-processed photo even though we now have the somewhat similar Camera Raw Filter available in Photoshop. The point here is that yes, there is a lot of overlap between most of these programs, and yes, they do things just different enough that they all present some benefits to your post-processing workflow. It is really just personal taste in how you want to adjust your images.

So here we are now with not one, not two, but three really good updated software programs (not to mention several other newer ones on the scene) that can process Camera Raw images and do pretty much everything Lightroom/ACR does. They are now all stand-alone programs or plugins for Photoshop layers. For website links to all three programs, check out my Tidbits Blog sidebar. Using the same image of Edinburgh Castle, the top one used Luminar 2018 for Windows, and below used On1 Raw 2018 and Topaz Studio. I tried to use a fairly similar workflow doing the basic Raw editing first and then adding in filter effects. So here is my take on where we are now.

All three of the above programs are really good – I am not going to bash any of them as they all do things I totally love. Do they overlap in what they do? Somewhat, but each has a few things I wish they all could do. Of course that is what sets them apart and why it is so hard to decide which one(s) to get.

To figure out which one would fit your workflow, you need to answer a pretty simple question: What do you want to do with your image or several of your future images? Where is your interest going – do you want to go more into an artistic feel or are you just trying to get the most realistic images for your profession or travel experiences? Since I do not have a professional studio or take wedding or senior photos often, I am more inclined to really stretch what the plugins will do to give an artistic feel to an image. Now I do understand that having a few quick tricks up your sleeve for clients to give them a choice of a few really artistic images is nice to have so using special effect plugins is just fine for that.

  • Topaz Studio

First, the Topaz Studio is a free download and contains several adjustments to get your started. Your older Topaz Labs filters can be accessed in this interface so you will always have access to them. You can’t go wrong with Topaz Studio’s Impression or one of their other creative Labs programs like Topaz ReStyle or Topaz Texture Effects for the really artistic effects. Impression has given Topaz the one-up on the other programs for the artistic effects and I am sure you have read lots about it – it is one of my favorite plugins. And I have to mention this little slider that lets you stop the painting action wherever you want – great addition to the updated filter. Topaz has done a terrific job with their masking effects tools and the different masking tools work really smoothly. The biggest down side is that even though Topaz Studio platform is free, to get it to work well you need to buy their Pro Pack. Therefore it brings it in line with the other two programs as far as cost goes. The Impression filter (or Clarity, Detail, or Simplify) needs to be bought individually to add into the Studio interface. If you already own Topaz Impression (or the other filters) as a Topaz Labs filter, you are entitled to a free upgrade for Studio (forever is their policy – once a filter is bought it is upgraded for free). And please do update to the newer Topaz Studio Impression filter – it is much better than the older Impression 2. If you own many Topaz filters, they will all eventually be added into the Studio interface. I am not going to say the program does not have its problems, but I do know enough by working with them that their final product will be very good. They have a Basic Adjustment that is not as complete as the others, but with the addition of the Clarity and Detail plug-ins, and several color adjustments choices, it is fine. In the image below, just a little more work on the clouds and some color reduction would really help and can be easily fixed in the program.

Image of Edinburgh Castle, Scotland - using Topaz Studio

  • On1 Photo Raw 2018

Photo Raw is now a really good challenger to Lightroom and is definitely worth checking out if you do lots of photo shoots. I have always liked On1 but it was very computer processor intensive. Their Browse Module is now lightening fast – it makes LR look really slow. I was stunned at how fast it all happens and it appears to be picking up my keywords from LR – that was even more amazing! And my computer hardly even cared. Once an image is chosen, go into their Develop Module which sets you up with the needed filters and is very similar to LR. Besides Shadow and Highlight sliders, there is a Midtone slider which I really like. There are other similar sliders to LR and includes a Detail section and Lens Correction section. Then it is time to go into the Effects Module where they provide lots of presets and individual filter choices. A very popular filter is called Dynamic Contrast – very similar to Detail in Topaz. Also the Glow filter is to be very popular. When masking, they do have a lot of choices (including a new Chisel Brush and Blur Brush) but I found it a little harder to use than in Topaz or LR. The filter settings can be somewhat hidden which includes the  blending options, and Highlight, Midtone, and Shadow sliders so the filter is only applied to certain areas if wanted. My biggest problem with On1 is the high learning curve. I believe it is a fantastic program and technically is going to keep Adobe on their toes. But it does take time to watch the videos to understand where everything is in the interface and what all the different filters will do. I can honestly say that On1 is totally improved from previous versions and I plan on using it a lot more. In the image below, the cloud color is just not quite right to me but the foreground sharpness is incredible! The clouds can be fixed easily in the program.

Image of Edinburgh Castle, Scotland using ON1 Photo Raw 2018

  • Luminar 2018

And now to Luminar 2018 – new entry for me into the field since I am a Windows person and this was for Mac previously. The image at the top of the blog is the Luminar example – loved the cloud effect especially and the Golden Hour filter on the front of the buildings. There are other parts I love and parts I hate it! Okay – if they would have updated it to match their Mac counterpart for us Windows users, I would love it. After watching several  videos just to find out all the sliders are not there, it is a bit frustrating. I also find that the Masking Tools are harder to use than with the other programs. The Mac version has several grouped filters for different types of effects – for Raw images an Essentials group was created which contains Tone, Accent AI, Color Temp, and Polarizing Filters. In Windows there are Filters Catalog but the Essentials is not the same group. This is definitely confusing. (Thank you Serge Ramelli for the video showing this filter set up – see Luminar 2018 vs Lightroom Classic?) But I love their filters and they seem to give a slightly different feel to an image – the Sun Ray filter, the Golden House filter, an Accent AI filter – and many others. Of the 3 image results shown, I liked the results from Luminar the best. I am under the assumption Luminar will be catching up the Windows version soon so it will work just like the Mac users interface. When that occurs, I will blog on this so everyone knows.

  • Bottom Line

I do love all these programs – have used Topaz and On1 for years – in fact my second favorite plugin from years ago was On1’s Photo Frame 4.6 – the best framing plug-in ever and I was totally upset when they discontinued it. BTW they do still have some framing options, but it is not quite the same – will blog on this soon. All three of my images are not that different – just some personal preferences there. And this was basically just using the Raw processors – each program has decidedly different strengths which are not showcased in these examples. A recent post by Photoshop Guru Matt Kloskowski called Is There a Lightroom Replacement explains in more detail about the browser and Raw converter issues – a good read. And check out my Related Blogs below for some other examples of what these programs can do.

As you can see things are changing as we come into a faster and more efficient software era. We have to say good-bye to some of the ways we used to post-process and attempt to figure out what to do with all the “Raw Converters!” – and what do we need from a filter program. I think so much of what you choose has to be based on just trying out the software now and seeing what works. Like I said, I am pleased, I am frustrated, and I am amazed at some of the filters I am now seeing. All three of these plug-ins are seasoned software companies and know what they are doing. Apparently Nik has been bought from Google recently by DxO and will be coming out this Spring with some updates. So there will be a new-old kid in town to really spice things up. Will I use their Raw converters for my work? Probably not so much – still a LR person at this point. Will I use their Special Effects filters? Totally!!! Hope this helped a little if you are as confused as me. I will continue updating you on all the new things coming out with these plug-ins but in the meantime, just try them out. It is amazing what some of the new filters are doing and it may fit just what you need for creating a new type of post-processing effect. In the meantime, Happy Black Friday if you are in the US and good luck finding some great PS finds!…..Digital Lady Syd

Digital Lady Syd Related Blogs:
Macphun Luminar 2018 Sun Rays at a Glance
Now Available – Free Beta Version of Macphun’s Luminar for Windows
Introducing the Free Topaz Studio
Updated Impression Now in Topaz Studio
Updated Clarity Now in Topaz Studio
How to Add a Simple Glow Effect to Your Image
A Beautiful View
My Favorite Photo Frame Plug-In – OnOne PhotoFrames (hum!) – just a little nostalgia here

14 responses

  1. I’m impressed you’ve been able to stay as current with the overwhelming amount of software (and hardware). We have so much assistance with capturing and editing our images now, we are digitally reimagining the world.

    As a Mac guy, I’m going to have to check out Luminar 2018. Sounds interesting. Thanks!

    11/18/2017 at 11:16 am

    • Thanks for the comment Gabe – I am not sure exactly where this is all going to end up but it is fun to follow. And do try out the Luminar program – it really intrigues me.

      11/18/2017 at 11:42 am

  2. PatCallahanPhotography

    Good info Syd! Thanks!

    11/18/2017 at 2:29 pm

  3. Dean

    Thank you for your insight and experience with these programs. I’ve gone ahead a purchased Luminar at the pre-release cost. I’m still on the fence regarding ON1 Photo RAW 2018. I can still get it at the pre-release cost, so it’s tempting. Any comments that would get me to commit would be appreciated. I currently use Lightroom Classic CC and Photoshop CC 2018. I also have ON1 Photo RAW 2017.

    Did you see Matt Kloskowski’s article on “Is There A Lightroom Replacement?”? – Posted 11/14/2017.

    Thanks Digital Lady Syd,


    11/20/2017 at 4:33 pm

    • Hi Dean – If I were you, I think I would download the trial of the new On1Photo Raw 2018 but leave your old one still in place. That way you can do a good comparison. On1 has definitely upped the masking features a lot which is something I really like, but the Develop module is very similar to LR. Check out Matt’s video on The Difference Between Develop and Effects at that I found really helpful on using Photo Raw 2018 since I am still using LR/PS. I really like a lot of their Effects filters but I am not quite sure what is new or updated with the 2018 version. Wish I had kept the 2017 version on my computer to see all the differences. Hope this helps a little.

      11/20/2017 at 10:54 pm

      • Dean

        Thanks Digital Lady Syd for the suggestions.

        If you go to the webpage through the URL below you’ll see (a little ways down on the page) a features comparison table between ON1 Photo RAW 2018 and ON1 Photo RAW 2017.6. After looking through this table I’ve decided that I can get by without the new features for the time being, and look at the ON1 Photo RAW 2019 when it comes out next year.

        Do you still have the ON1 Photo RAW 2017 download file? Mine says “ON1_Photo_RAW_2017.exe” which I download on 6/7/2017 (file size 837,545 KB). If you do, you can run it to re-install the program. If you don’t have the original download (or a copy), I can mail you a copy. Your license for your original 2017 should work.

        Thanks again,


        11/21/2017 at 10:41 am

  4. Considering I find it difficult to master the remote control for the tv, can you imagine how mind-boggling all of this is to me. I love your clear explanations on your blog. Makes it easier for someone as un-techie as me to get a grasp, thanks. 🙂

    11/21/2017 at 8:39 am

    • Thanks for the comment Jean – I am not at all that techie but I do get PS luckily! Glad I can pass some of the tips along.

      11/22/2017 at 4:19 pm

  5. Thanks for the info – excellent comparison chart. That does answer a lot of the questions about what exactly has changed. I did find my old exe file so I can reload it. I have a fairly small SSD drive and On1 loads only on it so I believe that is why I took the older version off. That is a problem for me but then that is also why it runs so smoothly on my computer. A choice you have to make. Thanks again for the info.

    11/21/2017 at 1:48 pm

    • Dean

      Your welcome. Sounds like it’s time for a bigger SSD.

      11/21/2017 at 2:38 pm

  6. Dean

    I saw that you said in this posting “…in fact my second favorite plug-in from years ago was On1’s Photo Frame 4.6.”

    I didn’t see a separate message interface specifically to you, so I’m placing this comment here in hopes you’ll come back to it someday and read it.

    I asked about his through ON1 support. Login into ON1. Click on “Account” and then on the right side you’ll see a section called “Products”. Click on the “View” link or any of the 4 icons and then go to the bottom of the page. You’ll see a product called “PhotoFrame Classic Borders & Textures Bundle”. Just click on that and then click on the “Go here to Download the PhotoFrame Classic Bundle” button. On that page are 17 links to down load the various parts of the bundle. I downloaded all of them, and the unzipped files totaled about 2GB.

    They do state that “These borders and textures will only work with versions of ON1 Photo 10 and ON1 Photo 2017 (Photo RAW)”. This may have been before ON1 Photo RAW 2018 came out so it might also work in the 2018 version.


    12/03/2017 at 5:06 pm

    • Hi Dean – I could find the PhotoFrame Class Borders & Textures Bundle link. I guess they have taken it off their site. Wish I had seen it. Have your tried it yet?

      12/04/2017 at 5:08 pm

      • Dean

        Hi Digital Lady Syd – That’s odd. I just logged in and the download links are still there. Are you an ON1 Plus member? I’m only a Plus member due to a bundle I purchased earlier this year. The picture for this link is a portrait of a young woman with long hair. The Photo Frame files have always been free. I can burn a copy of my files to a DVD and send them to you if you like. As far as trying it, I have not. I have installed the first file in ON1 Photo RAW 2017 just to make sure it would install correctly. It installed without a problem. I only have 16 more files to go.

        12/04/2017 at 10:52 pm

      • Dean

        I thought of this at the time, but for whatever reason I see I didn’t get it typed into the previous comment. You can email ON1 customer support and they should be able to give you a link to the same page I downloaded my “PhotoFrame Classic Borders & Textures” files from. Just a thought.

        Thanks, Dean

        12/13/2017 at 8:58 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.